I looked at the elders that i honored, and i know i talked to all of them, it was a boring month for me, so i went to every elder i could find using Wowhead. and the achievements page only showed me as finding 7-9 elders

We'll look into this.

---

Q u o t e:
I only talked to one this year (new baby kept me from doing much), but in years past I've talked to them all.

Only the one from this year is showing as completed. ><

I know that some holiday quests have been reset before, so I was thinking that might be why some (like this one) don't show correctly right now. Kind of sucks, but at least it's easy enough to redo next time the holiday rolls around.

---

All holiday recurring quests reset each year.

---

Q u o t e:


Does this mean that in order to keep the elder title, we will have to honor them all each year?

---

No. Achievements are a one way street. Once you get the achievement, it won't go away. That also means you keep the title.

The quests reset as a benefit to players who want to do them again.